PDA

View Full Version : Apple's iPhone: Is It Worth It?


FinnFreak
01-10-2007, 5:27am
Wall Street Journal - January 10, 2007


Apple's iPhone:
Is It Worth It?


http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/images/PJ-AJ443_pjAPPL_20070109181753.jpg


By NICK WINGFIELD and LI YUAN


APPLE INC.'s feverishly anticipated iPhone combines the music and video features of an iPod with the communications functions of a smartphone. The question is how many consumers will be willing to pay the hefty price for the combo.

The iPhone has a sleek design and is only 11.6 millimeters thick. A 3.5-inch screen, bigger than on most iPods, extends for almost the entire length of the nearly button-free device. Instead of the iPod's iconic scroll wheel, users will navigate through their song collections, make phone calls and perform other tasks by tapping their fingers on the iPhone's touch-sensitive screen. Users of the iPhone will make calls or type emails on a virtual keyboard that pops up onscreen as needed.

Apple, of Cupertino, Calif., has an exclusive agreement with AT&T Inc.'s Cingular, the nation's largest cellular carrier by subscriber, to sell the iPhone in the U.S. for $499 and $599 -- well above mass-market cellphones -- with a commitment to a two-year wireless plan. Although it has been on a hot streak, Apple doesn't always hit it big when it enters new markets. The company collaborated with Motorola Corp. on a phone called ROKR that plays songs from users' iTunes music collections, but it was seen by many as a disappointment because of limited storage capacity.

It's unclear if and when the prices for the iPhone might come down, as prices for electronics gear such as flat-screen television sets and video camcorders tend to do. While prices for the iPod have generally stayed in the same range over the years, consumers have been getting more features on new generations of iPods, essentially getting more for their money each time. With cellphones, the historical model has been for prices of such devices to come down quickly, with wireless carriers sometimes taking a loss on the products in order to get consumer subscription revenue.

In defense of the price of the iPhone, Apple Chief Executive Steve Jobs said in a speech at the start of the Macworld conference in San Francisco that consumers normally have to pay $199 for a comparable iPod nano and $299 for a smartphone, which would lack many of the whiz bang features of the iPhone at roughly the same price.

With Cingular, Apple developed a feature the companies described as a major innovation, calling it "visual voice mail." Instead of having to wade through voice mail messages in the order in which they were left, iPhone users will see a list with the names and phone numbers of people who left them voice messages and tap to listen the messages in whichever order they like.

There are also sophisticated sensors within the product that, for instance, adjust the brightness level of the screen to make it more legible based on ambient lighting conditions. Another sensor automatically shifts the screen-orientation of the iPhone to landscape from portrait mode when a user holds the device between two hands, which will allow users to view movies and television shows in wide-screen mode.

Initially, users will load music, video and other content onto the iPhone from their computers, not wirelessly over the Cingular network. Executives in the music industry say Apple will need to negotiate new licensing agreements with music labels to obtain rights to sell songs wirelessly on the iPhone.

In a nod to how drastically products like the iPod, iPhone and a new television set-top box coming out in February called Apple TV are reshaping the company, Apple yesterday said it has changed its corporate name to Apple Inc. after decades as Apple Computer Inc. In his speech, Mr. Jobs said the iPhone was the result of more than 2½ years of development work at Apple and positioned its importance on par with the two other biggest innovations in Apple's history, the Macintosh computer and iPod.

Mr. Jobs also said the company had worked with Yahoo Inc. and Google Inc. to bring popular Internet features like Yahoo Mail and Google Maps to the product. He said the iPhone is powered by Apple's Mac OS X operating system, which runs the company's line of computers.

All of the product's features come at a steep cost for consumers, though, leading some analysts to question how big Apple's opportunity is to tap the mass market, as it has with the iPod. Mr. Jobs said Apple was aiming to sell about 10 million iPhones through the end of 2008, which would account for about 1% of annual global shipments of cellphones.

But at $499 and $599, prices for versions of the iPhone with four gigabytes and eight gigabytes of storage capacity, respectively, Apple will be going after a fraction of the market. Toni Sacconaghi, an analyst at Sanford C. Bernstein, said cellphones priced above $300 account for only about 5% of the global market.

For its part, Cingular said it expects to attract high-end customers who are willing to pay the price of the device and for the data services the phone could offer, prices for which the companies didn't disclose. Cingular wouldn't say whether it was subsidizing the cost of the iPhone, as carriers typically do for most handsets. On average, North American carriers subsidize $70 to $90 per phone, according to research firm Gartner Inc.

Cingular CEO Stan Sigman said he was so convinced that Apple would come up with a breakthrough phone that Cingular signed a deal with Apple in New York two years ago without even seeing a product. The deal is a multiyear agreement, in which Cingular will handle customer support, billing and other chores. Through the deal, Apple is not becoming a mobile virtual network operator -- in effect, a reseller of airtime on another carrier's network.


http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/images/PJ-AJ444A_pjAPP_20070109212200.jpg
The Apple TV has a 40 gigabyte hard drive
and will be able to play video and photos
from PCs.


Apple also said its new Apple TV product, formerly called iTV, will go on sale in February for $299. The Apple TV, originally announced in September, will feature a 40 gigabyte hard drive and will be able to play video and photos from computers throughout the home.

Mr. Jobs said Viacom Inc.'s Paramount Pictures will join Walt Disney Co. in selling movie downloads that can be played on the Apple TV through the iTunes Store, providing more than 100 movies from its back catalog for download on iTunes.

To allay concerns of DVD retailers about competition from iTunes, Paramount is not including its new releases. Paramount studio head Brad Grey noted that the bulk of iTunes movie downloads so far have been library titles. Paramount's library includes movies such as "Breakfast at Tiffany's" as well as concert titles from artists like Bob Dylan and U2.


http://online.wsj.com/public/article/SB116839636912572211-k5XAtJ5N7BB_OAJd02EWBDlWtX0_20070209.html?mod=tff_ main_tff_top


www.apple.com/iphone



John - ;)

ELEANOR MAW
01-10-2007, 3:09pm
Apple's iPhone: I DON’T DISLIKE THE LOOKS, MOST i PODS LOOK LIKE A BAR OF SOAP.
I DON’T THINK IT WORTH IT. SONY ERICSSONS LOOK MUCH BETTER AND THE NEW ONES PLAY MP3 AND ARE VERY SEXY

FinnFreak
01-10-2007, 11:55pm
I feel somewhat disappointed: I was really expecting a handheld device in the footsteps of the Newton... the OS & GUI by itself doesn't consist as a killer app, IMO... but, it does look very sexy - and it will probably sell quite well because of that... the guys at Nokia are furious.


John - :p

Troll
01-11-2007, 12:03am
Thanks for the info.

Alex
01-12-2007, 12:54pm
Don't worth it for me. Rather my cell:D

FinnFreak
01-22-2007, 7:57am
heh... I've been getting plenty of inquiries from... lotsa different places... heck, the product isn't coming out for months - so, nobody knows for certain what the thing will contain the moment it hits the market... and, by the time it's supposed to be on sale in Europe - it could contain features we're still unaware of...


Still, I *did* take the keynote podcast down: darn great presentation..! :up:


Sceptics can say what they may - but the bottom line remains: Apple launched themselves into the mobile phone business with a blast.



Here's a FAQ on the iPhone, by David Pogue (The New York Times):


The Ultimate iPhone Frequently Asked Questions


Wow. Predictably, the torrent — and I do mean torrent — of iPhone commentary from the citizens of the Web is practically outflooding spam this week. Most of it comes from people whose shirt fronts are practically drenched in drool. Plenty is negative and bitter.

Another huge category is iPhone questions. Never mind that many of these questions either (a) have been answered by Apple, either on its elaborate, interactive Web site or the free video of Steve Jobs’s speech, or (b) come from people who fantasize about fitting the iPhone into their own particular wish lists.

(My favorite sarcastic comment, which was a response to these responses, which were in response to my last blog entry: “Yeah, yeah, yeah, but can you use it underwater? And can you recharge it using solar power? And does it have an optical scanner that detects your eyeball movements so that you merely have to look at a name in your contacts list and blink in order to choose and call him? Apple, you have a long way to go…”)

Anyway, here it is: the ultimate iPhone Frequently Asked Questions list, complete with answers.


ANSWERS TO ALL YOUR QUESTIONS:


Can it be used with anything but Cingular? –No.

Is it an “unlocked” phone, so I can use it with a carrier other than Cingular? –No.

Will there be a non-Cingular version? –Not within the first two years.

Can I put my T-Mobile SIM card in it instead of Cingular? –No.

But what if I keep asking? Then will it be available beyond Cingular? –No.

Can it run Mac OS X programs? –No.

Can I add new programs to it? –No. Apple wants to control the look and feel and behavior of every aspect of the phone.

Does it run programs from Palm, Symbian, Windows? –No.

Does it connect to iChat? –No.

Does it have games? –No.

Is it ambidextrous? –No.

Does it have GPS? –No.

Voice recognition? Voice dialing? Voice memos? –No, although this could change by June when the phone ships.

Does it get onto the HSDPA (3G) high-speed Internet network that Cingular has rolled out in a few cities? –No. But Steve Jobs said a later version of the iPhone will — once there’s enough HSDPA coverage in this country to justify it.

Does the Web browser support Flash or Java? –No.

Will it play music over Bluetooth? –Unknown.

Can you change the battery yourself? –No. You’ll have to send the phone in to Apple for battery replacement, just as with the iPods.

Can it open Word and Excel documents? –No. (Steve Jobs says it can open PDF files, though.)

Can you use it one-handed? –Yes, for some functions. But overall, it’s less convenient than on a phone with physical keys.

Can I make a call while driving a car? –Not as easily as on a regular cellphone with programmed speed-dial keys. (Besides–MUST you?)

Does the camera record video? –Not yet. Apple may add this feature by June.

Does it connect to standard iPod accessories like car docks and speaker systems? –Yes!

Does it work overseas? –Yes. It’s a quad-band GSM phone, meaning you can use it in almost any country (for an added fee, of course).

Is there a Verizon version? –NO!!!!

Will they make a non-cellphone version–a widescreen touch iPod? –Nobody knows. Apple doesn’t leak product info until it’s good and ready.

That scrolling through lists thing is glitzy, but what if I have 3,000 names in my address book? –There’s also an alphabet “index tab” down the right side of the screen, so you can jump to another spot in the list.

Is there a calendar? –Yes.

Will it sync with Outlook? –No.

What about airplane use? –It has a airplane mode (wireless off), just like any cellphone.

Won’t the screen get smudgy? –It does, but you don’t see it except when the screen is off. The one I played with was pretty streaky, but wiping it on my sleeve cleaned it completely.

Who on earth would buy this thing? –Obviously not people who ask this question. But that’s OK–there’s no requirement that everyone buy the iPhone. More for the rest of us!


Ultimate iPhone FAQs List, Part 2

Just got back home tonight after my week in San Francisco, and found ANOTHER several dozen questions about the iPhone waiting on this blog’s comments area!

I promise that this blog isn’t going to become “all iPhone, all the time”–but I’ve read through your comments and compiled this second list of Q’s and A’s.

First, though, a clarification on my earlier post…

“Will the browser offer Flash and Java?” –In my previous blog post, I said “No” (you’ll see why in a moment). But several of you have pointed out an interview published in the German magazine MacWelt, in which the browser IS said to offer Flash and Java.

So I’ve asked John Markoff, who audio-recorded our interview with Steve Jobs, to play back the relevant exchange for me. Here it is:

——

Markoff: “What about all those plugins that live within Safari now, like Flash or like Java or like JavaScript?”

Jobs: “Well, JavaScript’s built into the Phone. Sure.”

Markoff: “And what are you thinking about Flash and Java?”

Jobs: “Java’s not worth building in. Nobody uses Java anymore. It’s this big heavyweight ball and chain.”

Markoff: “Flash?”

Jobs: “Well, you might see that.”

Markoff: “What about YouTube–”

Jobs: “Yeah, YouTube—of course. But you don’t need to have Flash to show YouTube. All you need to do is deal with YouTube. And plus, we could get ‘em to up their video resolution at the same time, by using h.264 instead of the old codec.”

——-

So the DEFINITIVE answer now is: NO Java, MAYBE Flash.

Going on:

“Will we be able to assign ipod-playable songs to ringtones?” –John Markoff asked this during our interview, and Mr. Jobs said it’s not been decided yet.

“How does the iPhone charge?” –It comes with a white charging/syncing dock, just like an iPod.

“Also, are you SURE about the games? All the iPods run those special iPod games; wouldn’t you expect them to run those at least?” –Ooh, that’s a fantastic point. I explored the iPhone rather thoroughly during my time with it, and never saw any games. But it sure sounds logical that you’d at least get everything you get with a regular iPod!

“Another thing: what is the of OS X version? Is it close to Leopard, a mobile-Leopard?” –No. It’s not the entire Mac OS X, either, and of course the interface has been redesigned for phone use.

“The CALENDAR program, does it accept input on the phone, or is it just a dumb viewer of synced data from your mac, like the ipod is?” –Calendar program isn’t finished yet, but I did see an “add new event” icon on the placeholder graphic.

“Is there any wireless (Bluetooth or Wifi) syncing at all, for contacts and calendar?” –No.

“Is the SETTINGS menu working as of now, and what are some of the settings that you saw in there?” –Yes, it’s working! Some of the options I remember were: backlight timer; “show touch feedback” (a little dot appears on the screen every time you tap); airplane mode; ringtone. There were many pages of settings, though.

“How was call quality? Was this not available for testing?” –Yes, it was working fine. I called home with it. Sounded loud and clear, although this means nothing at this point. Apple doesn’t even have FCC approval yet, and have many months of fine-tuning and fiddling left to do. Also, of course, your call quality will depend on how far you are from the cell tower.

“How about going to Google spreadsheets and docs to open Word documents and spreadsheets?” –Should work, in theory!

“Can the pinch gesture be used on Web pages?” –Yes! Also on email! So weird, but cool–I could zoom in and out on an entire email message: embedded photo, text, and all.

“Are both text and images both (almost) infinitely resizable with the pinch gesture?” –No. The smallest size is “fit the whole thing on the screen.” The largest seems to be, I don’t know, 4X or 8X actual size.

“So there are no speed dial keys??” –That one’s been bothering me, too. Even according to the demo at apple.com/iphone, it seems as though to dial, starting from the Home screen, you have to tap the Phone icon, then the keypad icon OR the phonebook icon, THEN tap someone’s name. I can’t believe Apple would design something that requires so many steps. Surely they’ve got a quicker method up their sleeve…

“Or is it that the email will not sync?” –The email doesn’t sync with anything. It sends and receives email from the Internet.

“Will the built-in sensors replace the need of the Nike sports kit for tracking running data?” –You’re kidding me, right?

“Is there going to be a security logon, so that if it is stolen that it is essentially useless for non-hacker thieves?” –I didn’t see it, but since that’s standard on iPods, I would imagine that it’ll be there.

“Will any songs downloaded to the phone itself be able to be used as ringtones?” –Apple says it hasn’t decided.

“Will the iPhone work without a SIM card installed? i.e., will it be able to surf the web/email?” –Very doubtful.

“Is the speakerphone any good?” –Yes, very good (for a cellphone).

“Didn’t steve demo a feature where Google maps knew where the phone was? Wouldn’t that require GPS?” –No, he didn’t. (Yes, it would.)

“Will the iPod FM radio work ?” –I’d guess yes, but don’t know for sure.

“Do I HAVE to use Cingular?” –ARRRRRGGGHHH!

“Can the iPhone be used as a modem for a MacBook?” –If the answer were yes, Apple surely would have touted that feature.

“Will it support disk mode like ipods?” –I’m guessing yes. (I do have a call in to Apple for all these “I’m guessing” answers, but it seems they’ve been a little busy recently…)

“Can you use it with an existing Cingular account, or will Cingular have a special iPhone group of plans with special features like the priority voice mail, etc?” –Cingular hasn’t yet determined service pricing.

“You referred to the screen as being a ‘glass surface.’ Was it a figure of speech or is it really made out of glass?” –Figure of speech. It’s the same polycarbonate that’s used for iPod screens, although apparently the coating has been substantially improved.

“Does the screen scratch easily?” –See above.

“Do you really think Apple’s just going to sit on it and not work on improving it for the next half-year? Give it time.” –Could not agree more!

“Will the iPhone touch surface work if you’re wearing gloves? Be unpleasant to use the phone in the dead of winter otherwise.” –No, it responds ONLY to skin touch. I couldn’t use my fingernail, for example. And you certainly can’t use a stylus. (On the other hand, I doubt there’s ANY smartphone you can operate with gloves on.)

“If it doesn’t sync with Outlook, does that mean it will not be compatible with Windows OS?” –No, it’s definitely Windows-compatible, in that it syncs with iTunes. (Music, photos, videos, etc.)

“Was there discussion of the CPU type?” –Mr. Jobs would not say what the processor is.

“Can you use it with iPod headphones - that is a bud in each ear? Or is it a single bud like other phones?” — It comes with stereo earbuds with a microphone/switch on the cord, and any iPod-compatible earphones work.

“How did they get OS X on a 4mb phone?” –It’s four GIGABYTES, not megabytes. And it’s not the whole Mac OS X.

“No 3G is almost a deal breaker. EDGE is horrible for a device this advanced…how did that get overlooked?” –It wasn’t overlooked. 3G (HSDPA) is available only in a few cities. Apple says that when it’s more prevalent, the company will upgrade the iPhone.

“Any word on whether the keypad will be available in the horizontal screen mode allowing larger keys, albeit a smaller text window?” –That orientation wasn’t available in the prototype; Apple hasn’t decided whether or not to add the landscape keyboard layout. (Also, interestingly: rotating the iPhone to change the screen orientation only works counterclockwise–and only, as Mr. Jobs said, “When it makes sense.” That is, not all programs rotate.)

“I think it’s a bit backwards and disappointing for Apple to introduce a product that requires MORE visual attention than most phones, and which has no tactile means of operation.” –I agree. At this early date, I think the phone may be the weakest part of the iPhone.

“How bright was the screen?” –Very.

“Is the virtual keyboard at least as quick and easy to use as entering text with a regular cellphone’s number keys?” –I’d say it’s a wash. The “virtual” keys make it slower than a BlackBerry, but at least you have the whole alphabet; you don’t have to press the 1 key three times to get the letter C, or whatever.

“Why is everyone missing the fact that this phone/device will seamlessly switch between Edge and Wi-Fi saving big $$$ on data rates?” –Because nobody bothers to post about what they LIKE. If Internetters can’t say something disparaging, they say nothing at all.



Funny. heh.


John - ;)

aFinn
01-22-2007, 2:00pm
You mean it can only be used with Cingular? :huh:

FinnFreak
01-22-2007, 2:22pm
For the first two years: yes. (at least in the U.S.)

That's what the exclusive deal means. Some of those services and technology are patent protected & Apple has over 200 patents with iPhone... and you can bet they will want to sell licenses. And at first, there will probably be only one operator in Europe as well. Like, let's say Vodaphone & partnership companies (like Elisa).


John - :)

aFinn
01-22-2007, 2:28pm
Forgot to put a :p in my previous post :p

On the subject of iPhone: no thanks from me.

FinnFreak
01-22-2007, 2:59pm
...in a couple of years, you just might change your mind - those guys at Apple are the Kings of Hype... and their market share on the "smartphone" segment *will* be a double digit percentage in 5 years...


iKnow it.


John - :p

aFinn
01-24-2007, 4:07am
All the hype does not help if I'm not interested in the product :p

FinnFreak
01-24-2007, 6:07am
There's no hype in Europe yet, so it's quite understandable. :p

...and even if they introduced 3G this year... so..? Where's one gonna use it..? - *only* inside Kehä III..? :huh:


:uhh: - riiiiiight... heh. ;)


I'd first like to see the iTunes Store updated over here as well. :smirk:


John - :)

ELEANOR MAW
01-24-2007, 9:31am
In less they make the big screen very Strong, the Apple's iPhone could easily get damaged.

tonyme
01-24-2007, 2:56pm
Even if I think the iPhone isn't really worth it... It's just an iPod+phone... I think it's gonna be well-received...

Especially in countries where the iPod was well received;)

FinnFreak
01-25-2007, 1:00am
All the hype does not help if I'm not interested in the product :p

...and that's also what Mi¢ro$oft's Bill Gates first said about the Internet... :p


John - ;)